dekonr wrote:I appreciate your careful review, but I need to correct some of your points: [...]
r1: Parsing
just the logs I [still] have on the two toons I use most, I've over 300 grey runs of Scion/Anathema/Crucible. While the most common result is 2p+{3-7}g, followed by 3.x plat ... there's nearly ask many 1.x as 5.x plat chests. I think it's fair to say you can reasonably expect 6-9p for the three EFs, but might see as little as 3p or as much as 15p from time to time.
r2: You're right -- I was thinking about sharding. The beholder-esque mob and tomb mob are easy solo.
mea culpa
r3: I've done CoA (green'd) for alt loot during several GUs -- and I've never seen a mentored CoA chest give me coin (I try every time!)
r4: You implied they could be solo'd, but with difficulty. You never said they couldn't (and, they can -- not easily).
r4b: Yup, I've killed the Jailor solo before on most toons. But if you're not interrupting him, and not high DPS, you can find yourself out of room from moving him around. I wouldn't presume an L75 in MC/Expert is going to kill the Jailor, unless one of a minority of classes; at L80 in raid gear, most should be able to. There's a lot of toons in-between.
r5: I tested the EF three just before GU54 hit, and in all three, greyed-out = chest gave nothing when opened (i.e.: greened in key mob to get key, dropped mentor, clicked chest). Same for HoF (someone needed an Eidolon kill). I'd be happy if they'd let me collect Befallen plat they way I do Mirgul plat.
Really, with edits, it's a solid guide to "Typically making 6-9p daily from grey running Everfrost shard instances in ~30 mins". Instead it goes with an implied "do this with all grey shard zones you created" and half-retreats with "This is easiest by far in Everfrost" (meaning the others are solo'able, but EF is easiest).
So what's pumped as a guide to eight "guaranteed" 3-5p chests daily, is really for three chests without a guarantee. But even without the mislead, I stand by my nay -- good guide, worth TUBs, not worth premium on its own.
I appreciate your taking the time to post the guide, and look forward to more good work in the future.
Edit: Checked (15 Dec 09), and a mentored-but-green CoA still gave no coin from opening the shard chest. =/
Edit 2: Checked (17 Dec 09) -- Crucible and Scion *did* give coin while opening chest grey; Halls of the Forsaked did NOT.
Edit 3: Checked (19 Dec 09) -- Anathema *did* give coin from chest opened while grey. So EF/Miraguls zones are THE way to go.