Nay
Because of
zycamzip (!empty($user->lang['WROTE'])) ? $user->lang['WROTE'] : ucwords(strtolower(str_replace('_', ' ', 'WROTE'))):
Sorry, but its not a guide, it's screenshots. A guide is much more informative. Perhaps if you rewrote it, with a noob in mind, stating all the basic facts, what they need to get started, the process, which herbs are catalysts, which are not, etc... then that could be stated as being a guide.
All I can say is be glad this is not a learning process like the original AC. What was it 1/20 people had the same tapers to cast and learn a spell?
and for some reason, after reading some of your posts sk420, it doesn't seem that you fully understand what you're talking about.
"Basic herbalism"? Is there advanced herbalism? What does your thread say at all about alchemy? That you have a screenie of a potion you can make, doesn't really say anything. Which two tables are you referring to? Your two screenshots? They hardly tell anything, especially if you're not ingame and know how to interpret the screenies.